How One-to-One Literacy Tutoring Can Help First Graders Become Stronger Readers

Daily one-to-one literacy tutoring gives first graders focused practice that's hard to fit into a full classroom. Here's what the research says about why it works, and how you can help bring it to public school first graders reading below grade level.

Share This Post

A first grader looks at the word ship and reads it as “s-h-ip.”

Her tutor stops her right there. “When s and h sit next to each other, they team up to make one sound: /sh/. Try it again.”

She does. Ship. Then shop, fish, shell.

That exchange took less than a minute. In it, a child got a clear explanation, tried again right away, and practiced until the skill stuck. In a classroom of 25 students, that moment might not happen today. In one-to-one tutoring, moments like that happen throughout the session.

Children don’t all learn to read at the same pace. Some first graders connect letters and sounds quickly. Others need more time, more practice, or a different explanation for a skill to click. High-quality, one-to-one literacy tutoring gives those children something hard to replicate in a full classroom: focused time with a tutor who can respond to exactly what they know and what they need to practice next.

That’s additional support, not a replacement for the classroom. Teachers remain at the center of a child’s education. They present new skills, build vocabulary, and support many children with different needs every day. Even the best teacher can’t easily pause the whole class every time one child mixes up b and d. Tutoring fills that gap.

Does literacy tutoring work?

The research here is strong.

A large meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials, published in the American Educational Research Journal, found that tutoring produced consistent, substantial gains in student learning. The effects were largest in the earlier grades, in programs that met at least three times a week, and in programs held during the school day.

That last part matters. The research doesn’t say tutoring works simply because it’s called tutoring. It shows that how tutoring is designed, including when it happens, how often, and for whom, makes a real difference.


What makes literacy tutoring effective?

Picture a first grader who knows most of her letter sounds but can’t yet blend them into words. In a one-to-one session, the tutor can listen as she reads and hear exactly where she gets stuck. The tutor can model the skill, have her try again, and move on once she has it. Effective tutoring brings together a few things. 

  • Individual attention. One-to-one tutoring lets a tutor focus closely on how a child reads and identify the specific skills they need support with. 
  • Immediate feedback. When a child reads a word incorrectly or struggles with a skill, a tutor can respond in the moment—helping them correct the error and practice the skill accurately.
  • Repetition and consistency. Regular tutoring gives children repeated opportunities to practice and strengthen new reading skills, building on what they learned in one session and carrying it into the next. 
  • Progress monitoring. Effective tutoring responds to a child’s progress. As skills develop, instruction can adjust so the student continues working on what they need next.

What the Science of Reading actually means

You’ll often hear “the Science of Reading” used as if it were a curriculum or a branded program. It isn’t.
It’s a large body of research from education, psychology, cognitive science, and neuroscience about how children learn to read and which teaching practices help. A central finding is that reading doesn’t come naturally the way speaking does. The brain has to be taught to connect sounds to letters.

For beginning readers, the U.S. Department of Education’s What Works Clearinghouse makes four recommendations for teaching foundational reading skills in kindergarten through third grade. Three focus directly on how children learn to read words: help children hear the sounds in spoken words and connect them to letters; teach them to decode words and recognize word parts; and have them read connected text every day to build accuracy, fluency, and comprehension. The fourth focuses on building academic language and vocabulary.

That’s why good tutoring isn’t just extra time with a book. In a single session, a tutor might have a child pick out the sounds in a word, match them to letters, blend them, practice the pattern across several words, and then read it in a sentence. The goal isn’t memorizing or guessing. It’s building the skills that let a child read words accurately and understand them.


Why systematic, explicit instruction matters

For a child reading below grade level, more practice alone may not be enough. What they practice matters too. Two words come up again and again in reading research: systematic and explicit.

Explicit means skills are taught directly. Instead of hoping a child notices that s and h make one sound, the tutor tells them, shows them, and has them practice.

Systematic means skills are taught in a planned order, with each new one building on the last. Children learn individual letter sounds before blending, and short vowels before trickier vowel teams.

One-to-one tutoring makes this kind of instruction especially responsive. If a child has mastered a skill, the tutor moves forward. If not, the tutor slows down, models it again, and gives more chances to practice. It’s not just more instruction. It’s more focused instruction.


Can 15 minutes of reading tutoring really make a difference?

Fifteen minutes doesn’t sound like much, and a single session won’t transform a child’s reading. That’s not the idea.

The difference comes from consistency. Fifteen minutes a day becomes more than an hour of individualized practice each week, and dozens of hours across a school year. Because every minute is tailored to one child, very little of that time goes to skills they already have.

Research backs this up. A Johns Hopkins University evaluation of a program built on daily 15-minute one-to-one sessions found that tutored first graders outperformed similar students who didn’t receive tutoring. Of the students who finished first grade reading at benchmark, 85% were still on benchmark at the beginning of third grade, without additional tutoring. Daily 1:1 literacy tutoring aligned with the Science of Reading increased the share of low-income first graders reading on grade level from 6% to 48% in a single school year. And as the meta-analysis found, tutoring works best when it happens frequently and during the school day.

Fifteen minutes doesn’t magically solve literacy. But focused time, repeated day after day, gives a child steady chances to learn, practice, and build on what they know.


One child. One tutor. Every school day.

Reading below grade level in first grade doesn’t determine a child’s future as a reader. It’s a sign that they may need more focused support while foundational reading skills are still developing. With evidence-based instruction, consistent practice, and focused support, children gain the skills needed to become confident, fluent readers. 

Tutoring works; the challenge has been paying for it. Starting January 1, 2027, the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit (FSTC), also known as the Education Freedom Tax Credit (EFTC), lets taxpayers redirect up to $1,700 of the federal taxes they already owe into literacy tutoring scholarships. 

EducationSuperHighway uses those contributions to fund literacy tutoring scholarships for eligible first graders in public schools who are reading below grade level. These scholarships provide daily, one-to-one literacy tutoring grounded in the Science of Reading, providing focused support at a critical point in their reading journey.

You can help a child learn to read. Sign Up Today, and we’ll contact you the moment you can give.

This information is for educational purposes only and is not tax, legal, or financial advice. Your eligibility for the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit depends on your individual tax situation, including your federal tax liability. The credit is nonrefundable and applies only to qualifying cash contributions made on or after January 1, 2027. Program rules are based on proposed Treasury and IRS regulations and may change. Consult a qualified tax professional.

WHY EDUCATIONSUPERHIGHWAY?

Why Trust Us With Your Donation?

EducationSuperHighway was founded in 2012. Over a decade, EducationSuperHighway led the national effort to close the K-12 broadband gap — connecting 99.3% of America’s K-12 public schools to high-speed internet and 5 million low-income households to affordable broadband.

Today, EducationSuperHighway is turning those connections into opportunity. As a 501(c)(3) non-profit Scholarship Granting Organization, we are focused on closing the nation’s literacy gap — one first-grader at a time.

© 2026 EducationSuperHighway · A 501(c)(3) non-profit Scholarship Granting Organization. Our tools and resources are provided for educational purposes only and do not constitute tax, legal, or financial advice. Always consult a qualified tax professional. Credit regulations are subject to IRS finalization. · Official Tax Credit Fact Sheet.